Quiet slate-blue harbor beside a granite seawall and gray-shingled waterfront homes in late-autumn afternoon light.

Eight Neighborhoods, One Harbor: What Wentworth by the Sea Homes Sell For in New Castle

November 19, 2026

In April 2026, the most expensive home sold anywhere on the New Hampshire Seacoast was a condominium. Granite Post News reported that the three-story, 4,352-square-foot unit at 167 Little Harbor Road in New Castle sold for $4.9 million. That was nearly $1.5 million more than the month's runner-up, a Frank Jones-built single-family house at Rye Beach. The unit sits next to the Wentworth marina and looks out to the Isles of Shoals. Its association has a pool, tennis and pickleball courts.

The same thing had happened less than a year before. In July 2025, the biggest condominium sale across the Seacoast Board of Realtors' 13 sample towns was 24 Mill Pond Road in New Castle, a waterfront unit that closed at $3.4 million, $5,000 over its list price, according to Patch. Both homes are in Wentworth by the Sea, the planned community that surrounds the hotel and marina on New Castle's Little Harbor side.

If you're comparing New Castle with Rye, Portsmouth or North Hampton, these two sales explain how this part of the island works. In Wentworth by the Sea, "condominium" describes how a home is held. It doesn't tell you what kind of home it is or what it costs. Some of the community's condos are among the most expensive waterfront homes in the region. Regional condo statistics and the usual condo-versus-house shortcut both fail here. Price depends on which of the community's eight neighborhoods a home is in and how it sits on the water.

A Regional Condo Median That Doesn't Reach This Far

The Seacoast Board's October 2026 report, covered by Patch on November 10, puts the 13-town condo median for that month at $594,500 across 54 sales. The single-family median for the same month was $791,250 across 78 sales. Those figures describe Portsmouth's downtown flats, Exeter's townhouses and Hampton's beach units well. They say little about Wentworth by the Sea, where condo closings over the past year and a half have been five to eight times that October median.

Here, the condo label is the ownership form attached to a waterfront townhouse with association grounds behind it. The Dockside unit that sold in April is one of six waterfront townhouses in that neighborhood. Owners share a pool, beach access and courts. So a buyer who filters out condos to stay in a single-family budget, or filters for condos expecting a lower price, will get a wrong picture of this part of town.

One Community Built Around a Hotel

The Wentworth By The Sea community association describes 107 single-family and condominium homes on roughly 100 acres. Those acres also hold the Wentworth By The Sea Hotel and Spa, the Wentworth Marina and nearly 20 acres of open space with a pool, three tennis courts and clubhouse facilities. The marina has 170 boat slips, a fuel dock and launch service to moorings in Little Harbor.

The homes are grouped into eight neighborhoods: Campbells Island, Dockside, Ducks Head, Great Island, Harborview, Little Harbor, Marina Heights and Mill Pond. Each one went up in its own phase. Ducks Head came first, with 21 Cape Cod homes designed by Royal Barry Wills, some on the water and some with water views. Great Island Condominium came last. Its four townhouses at the corner of Campbell's Island Lane and Wentworth Road, across from the hotel's main entrance, were finished around 2003.

The hotel itself had been dark for two decades by then. A 2002 Portsmouth Herald report gives 1982 as its closing year and spring 2003 as the target for finishing the renovation. Today its restaurants, Salt Kitchen + Bar and Latitudes, draw diners from across the Seacoast. The community's homes grew up around a resort that came back, and the grounds, marina and dining are part of the address in a way they aren't for a house in New Castle's village.

Two Associations on One Deed

Wentworth by the Sea has a structure that most New Castle homes don't. The community association's own description says every owner belongs to two associations: the Master Association that covers all eight neighborhoods and a separate association for their own neighborhood. Homeowners elect the master board, which controls and manages certain common lands and property, including some roads and utilities. All owners pay regular assessments for operating, maintaining and repairing that common property. Each year they also pay a capital reserve assessment for larger projects, and the association names road paving as an example.

Utility bills come from two municipalities. The Town of New Castle bills each homeowner for sewer and the City of Portsmouth bills for water. To compare a Wentworth home's costs with a village house on Piscataqua Street or a Rye listing, your cost sheet needs both association layers, the reserve assessment and both utility bills. Recent listing sheets in the community show association charges with billing periods that differ or aren't stated. Get the current master and neighborhood assessments in writing for the specific home before you compare it with anything.

The town tax side is changing this year. New Hampshire's Department of Revenue Administration set New Castle's 2025 total rate at $5.73 per $1,000 of assessed value on October 30, 2025. In the Select Board's September 1, 2026 minutes, the chair noted that town values had risen 65% over five years in the Avitar revaluation. He said the rate was expected to fall, would be set in October or November, and that bills go out and come due in December. We covered that reset in more detail in our September look at New Castle's tax and insurance picture. These figures are general information, not tax, legal or financial advice, so check your own numbers with the town, the association and your own advisors.

Where the Water Sets the Price

The association layers are the same across all eight neighborhoods, so they don't explain why one Wentworth home sells for twice what another does. Position on the water does. A broker tally of the nine sales in the five most active neighborhoods from January 2023 through November 2025 shows the range. Three Mill Pond sales averaged about $2.73 million. Two Ducks Head sales averaged about $3.1 million, and a single Harborview sale closed at $3.2 million. Two Little Harbor sales averaged $4.085 million, and Campbell's Island's one sale was about $4.8 million.

Sales over the past 14 months show the same spread. On Old Bay Road, inside the community, homes closed at $2.1 million in October 2025, $2.225 million in December 2025 and $2.425 million in August 2026. On Little Harbor Road, 65 Little Harbor closed at $3.335 million in July 2026, and the Dockside townhouse at 167 Little Harbor brought $4.9 million in April. All five homes share the same master association, clubhouse, pool and courts. The Little Harbor Road homes sold for well above the Old Bay Road homes because of where they sit on the water. Whether a home was a condo or a single-family house made no consistent difference.

The pace of sales matters as much as the prices. Nine sales in nearly three years across the five most active neighborhoods means some neighborhoods go a year or more with no sale at all. With so few sales, one closing can move a neighborhood's average by hundreds of thousands of dollars. A buyer who wants a specific neighborhood, such as a Ducks Head Cape or a Dockside townhouse, may find nothing for sale in it for a long stretch. A seller pricing a Mill Pond home can't borrow comparable sales from Little Harbor, even though the two are a short walk apart.

The Rest of the Island Prices Differently

Outside the association, New Castle's prices depend on different things. Patch's July 2025 report recorded the month's biggest single-family sale at 40 Ocean Street in New Castle: an oceanfront Victorian on about a third of an acre that closed at its full $4.5 million asking price while needing extensive renovation. That price paid for the lot and the ocean frontage, not for finished space or shared amenities. In the village, 7 Piscataqua Street, a single-family home, sold for $1.3 million on October 16, 2026.

So one small town has two pricing systems. In the village and on the open-ocean lots, value comes from the land, the age of the house and what it would take to restore it. Inside Wentworth by the Sea, value comes from which neighborhood a home is in and how it faces Little Harbor or the marina, with association grounds and the hotel at the center. Our New Castle neighborhood guide covers the island as a whole. A buyer weighing a Wentworth home against a village house is really comparing two different markets in one town.

Short Answers

Is a Wentworth by the Sea condo a lower-cost way into New Castle? Not by recent sales. The two highest-profile condo closings in the community were $3.4 million in July 2025 and $4.9 million in April 2026, and each led the Seacoast condo market for its month.

Is the Wentworth by the Sea Country Club part of the community? The club is across the harbor in Rye. The association describes it as across the harbor from the community, with its own 18-hole golf course, a swimming pool, indoor and outdoor tennis courts, a fitness center and a clubhouse.

Why do prices in one neighborhood swing so much from year to year? There are very few sales. With a single closing in some neighborhoods over nearly three years, one waterfront sale can move an average more than any market trend does.

If you own one of the 107 homes at Wentworth by the Sea, its value depends on which neighborhood it's in and where it sits on the water, and a townwide median won't show that. To find out where your home stands, request a free home valuation from The Sea Coast Agency. If you'd like a quieter sale, you can also tell us about your home through our off-market listing form.

Discover the Difference

We are committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, we've got you covered.