Gray clapboard entry with a charcoal door, weathered granite steps and rust-colored oakleaf hydrangeas in late-fall light.

Between Trick-or-Treat and the Tree Lighting: New Castle's Homemade Late-Fall Calendar

October 22, 2026

Back in June, the island's town newsletter carried a short item from the New Castle Congregational Church Guild. Its crafts group was meeting in the Parish Hall on Mondays at 9:30 a.m. Two Guild members were leading the work, and the goal was a stock of gifts for the December Christmas and Greens Fair. So the fair on Saturday, December 5, was already being made by hand before most of the island had opened its summer furniture.

That early start fits the rest of the season. Look at what's on New Castle's calendar from trick-or-treat to early December and nearly all of it comes from the island itself: the town, the library, the Historical Society, the Guild. Wentworth by the Sea adds its Illumination and its two holiday meals, and those are the only commercial dates on the list.

Friday Night on the Streets

The season starts tomorrow, Friday, October 30. The town calendar lists Trick or Treat from 5 to 7 p.m. The town sets that window, and it's the same two hours for every street on the island.

The next town date comes four days later. The town newsletter lists the General Election for Tuesday, November 3. After that, the calendar is mostly in the hands of the island's own groups.

Thursday, November 5, at 120 Main Street

The New Castle Historical Society holds its last program of the year together with its annual meeting. On Thursday, November 5, at 7 p.m., Jack Beard will give a talk at the Society's museum at 120 Main Street called "The Jaffery Cottage of New Castle." According to the Historical Society's events page, Beard once lived in the historic cottage, and the Society has posted a Zoom link for people who can't make it in person.

The talk wraps up a year of monthly programs. The September and October talks were both held at the Parish Hall, the same room where the Guild's crafts group meets. In September, Diana Schulte spoke about the Blue Ocean Society. In October, David Pepson covered the murals at the Warner House in Portsmouth. The spring line-up stayed close to the water too: Ann Beattie on cod fishing at the Isles of Shoals, then river pilot and tugboat captain Chris Holt on guiding tankers up and down the Piscataqua.

Behind the talks, the Society has a much slower project going. For the past 12 years, its volunteers have been cataloging and scanning what they call the Fragment Files. These are fragile, handwritten documents kept in the Town Hall vault, dating from 1693 to 1942. They include tax lists, governors' proclamations, lists of schooners owned by island residents, names of ferries and taverns, and records of repairs to the meeting house and bridges. One fragment from 1776 asks for a bridge from the upper end of New Castle to Ward's Island, now Goat Island, and from there to Adam's Island, now Shapleigh Island. The idea was to give residents a safe retreat to Fort Washington on Peirce Island if the enemy attacked.

As of the June newsletter, the team had catalogued about 1,600 documents and reached the year 1853. All of those are searchable in the Society's online catalog. The work became more pressing after the Select Board found mold in the Town Hall vault. That vault also holds leather-bound town meeting minutes, account books from local businesses, scrapbooks and photo albums. So when the members gather on November 5, they're a group with a real deadline.

The Library's November Is Hands-On

The New Castle Public Library fills the middle of the month. Its November calendar lists the regular knitting, Story Time, and Strength & Conditioning sessions. Three programs are added on top:

  1. Wednesday, November 11, 2 p.m. "From Assessment to Action," the third and last session of a Functional Movement Assessment series led by Katie D'Amato, a Doctor of Physical Therapy. According to the series flyer, you need to have attended the first session on October 14 to take full part.
  2. Tuesday, November 17, noon. Winter Book Share. Bring a book recommendation and RSVP. The Book Share flyer caps attendance at 15.
  3. Wednesday, November 18, 2 p.m. Learn to Make Sourdough Focaccia. The sourdough flyer says registration is required.

Two of the three need a sign-up, and the Book Share holds only 15 people, so it helps to reserve early. December looks quieter. The December calendar shows the regular sessions and the holiday closures, with no special programs. If a library program is on your list for the season, November is the month for it.

The last town chore of the season falls on the Saturday after the focaccia class. November 21 is the year's final Green Waste Day, from 8 to 11 a.m. It's on the right side of the recreation building at 301 Wentworth Road, next to the old rifle range, in the gray concrete building. The newsletter lists no Green Waste dates after November, so any fall cleanup left after that day waits until next year.

December 1 Belongs to Someone Else

Wentworth by the Sea hosts the season's one big evening event. Illumination is on Tuesday, December 1, from 5 to 7 p.m. The Wentworth's holiday page lists carolers, horse-drawn carriage rides with Santa, the Portsmouth High School Marching Band, and holiday crafts and games. The tree gets lit that night, and guests gather around this year's giant gingerbread house.

The resort also covers both holiday meals. On Thanksgiving, Thursday, November 26, the Wentworth Ballroom serves a buffet from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Salt serves dinner from noon to 8 p.m. Maple-brined turkey is on the menu, and reservations go through 603.373.6566. For Christmas, the ballroom buffet runs 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Salt again serves noon to 8 p.m. The page describes maple-glazed ham, roasted salmon, a Belgian waffle station, a raw bar and a carving station.

Those meals and the Illumination make up the island's commercial holiday season, all at one address on the hill. Four days after the tree lighting, the calendar goes back to the volunteers.

Saturday, December 5, and the Months Behind It

The town calendar lists the Christmas Fair on Saturday, December 5, as an all-day event. This is the fair the Guild's crafts group was making gifts for back in June.

The Guild's fair page still shows last year's details. The 2025 fair ran from 8 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. on December 6 at the New Castle Recreation Center. That year's tables had wreaths, swags, centerpieces, baked goods, fudge, Guild-made ornaments, used jewelry, animal-related gifts and raffle chances. Before you go this year, check the town's event listing for the 2026 hours and location.

The Guild calls itself a non-denominational group that raises money for local charities. The fair is the last stop on its calendar. Earlier in the year came the Juried Arts and Crafts Sale on July 25, known for its strawberry shortcake, and an evening sale of donated local art in the Parish Hall. The Guild also turns up at other groups' events. At the Great Island Garden Club's plant sale in May, Guild members sold baked goods.

The Garden Club does much of its work all year, in plain view. Its members plant and look after the Island Boat Garden, the Town Hall planters, the Post Office window boxes, the Public Safety Building planters and garden, the Village Garden, the Town Landing and Ornamental Grass Garden, the Common gatehouse planters and the Recreation Center garden. If the village looks dressed for the season when you walk to the fair on December 5, that's mostly the Garden Club's work.

The Season on One Page

Date Event Run by Where
Fri., Oct. 30, 5–7 p.m. Trick or Treat Town of New Castle Island-wide
Tue., Nov. 3 General Election Town of New Castle See town notices
Thu., Nov. 5, 7 p.m. Annual meeting and "The Jaffery Cottage of New Castle" New Castle Historical Society NCHS Museum, 120 Main St., plus Zoom
Wed., Nov. 11, 2 p.m. Movement assessment, session three New Castle Public Library Library
Tue., Nov. 17, noon Winter Book Share, RSVP, 15 max New Castle Public Library Library
Wed., Nov. 18, 2 p.m. Learn to Make Sourdough Focaccia, registration required New Castle Public Library Library
Sat., Nov. 21, 8–11 a.m. Final Green Waste Day of 2026 Town of New Castle 301 Wentworth Rd.
Thu., Nov. 26 Thanksgiving buffet and dinner Wentworth by the Sea Wentworth Ballroom and Salt
Tue., Dec. 1, 5–7 p.m. Illumination Wentworth by the Sea Wentworth by the Sea
Sat., Dec. 5, all day Christmas Fair Congregational Church Guild Check town calendar

Eight of these ten entries come from the town, the library, the Historical Society and the Guild. The other two are at the Wentworth. For more on how the island's public spaces move through the seasons, our guide to the New Castle loop follows what closes and when, and our New Castle neighborhood page covers the island more broadly.

At SellingTheSeacoast, we keep track of the island's calendar because these volunteer-run dates are part of what makes a New Castle address what it is. If you're thinking about what your own home is worth heading into the holidays, Emil and Jackie would be glad to give you a clear, local answer. Request a Free Home Valuation.

Discover the Difference

We are committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, we've got you covered.